← All summaries

Miranda Is Not the Villain, with The Devil Wears Prada 2's Writer & Director

On with Kara Swisher · Kara Swisher — Aline Brosh McKenna, David Frankel · May 4, 2026 · Original

Most important take away

The Devil Wears Prada 2 frames Miranda Priestly as the hero, not the villain — a deliberate inversion that mirrors how today’s audiences view brilliant, demanding leaders (especially women) versus the Trump/Bezos/Musk-style billionaires now squeezing the media businesses she runs. The deeper insight: the entire institutional context of cultural authority — magazine editors, journalism careers, mid-budget films — has collapsed in 20 years, and the sequel works because it treats that collapse as the actual subject.

Summary

Key themes:

  1. Miranda is the hero, not the villain. McKenna explicitly pitched the original to the studio as “Miranda is the heroine — she’s trying to achieve excellence every day. Why does she have to be nice to do it?” Streep has long said: if Miranda were a man, there’d be no movie — the brilliant-asshole-as-genius male trope is everywhere. The sequel leans further in: Miranda is shown vulnerable, accepting help, and aware she “needs to rein it in” but uncomfortable with that.

  2. Power-dynamics lens has flipped. The first movie was first-person Andy looking up at her terrifying boss. The sequel puts Andy in middle management — you see your boss up close and realize they’re fallible. McKenna compares it to growing up and realizing your parents are fallible.

  3. Journalism (and Hollywood, and law, soon medicine) is in measurable decline. Frankel cites a major bank CEO telling him AI may impact ~100,000 of her people. He warns LA “has become a very bleak place” and the industry will shrink “even more in the next five years.” Their challenge: where do you point your 24-year-old kids?

  4. AI is the iceberg the sequel quietly addresses. Frankel: AI will surprise us — music is the canary in the coal mine; people already can’t reliably distinguish machine-made tracks from human-sweat work. He expects AI to roll over film “like the lava of Pompeii.” McKenna is more skeptical based on how dumb current chatbots still are at basic tasks (gave her wrong day-of-week, sent her to closed restaurants), but acknowledges this prediction will age poorly.

  5. The billionaire-tech-mogul-buying-media plot is right out of 2026. Justin Theroux’s Benji Barnes is “Bezos with a touch of Musk” plus a Jeff-Bezos/Mackenzie-Scott reference for Lucy Liu’s ex-wife. He’s deeply read on history (memorizes Roman/Venetian tomes), running an “aqua deficit,” wanting to send a rocket to the sun, and capable of forgetting he owns a particular house. He’s the menacing-bouncy-toddler archetype of the new owners.

  6. What’s lost when not-core-business owners take over media: McKenna: “When it’s not their core business, they can delete it like that… they can wake up any day and go ‘never mind. This is too much trouble.’” Stability that used to define Hollywood/journalism careers is gone — you must now read the trades obsessively because the landscape changes daily.

  7. People crave authentic, in-person, original work. Crowds running into the street during shooting; Streep/Hathaway global tour was pandemonium. Audiences are reacting against the AI/uncanny aesthetic. Original films breaking through (One Battle After Another, Sinners, Weapons) signal that the appetite for human-made craft is real.

  8. Mid-budget films starring women are nearly extinct as theatrical releases. Even with the original’s track record, the team isn’t sure it would get a theatrical greenlight today vs. a streamer. The bar now is: can it earn its keep theatrically? Anything for women is treated as a market surprise even after repeated success.

  9. Cultural authority has fragmented and been deci-fied. Lindsay Peoples (editor-in-chief of The Cut) asks: does the room with someone like Miranda even still exist? McKenna: there’s no Walter Cronkite, no Diana Vreeland — even Anna Wintour or Madonna are unknown to most younger audiences. “It’s important to dream of something that exists” — set your cap for something else.

  10. The “vicarious thrill” of transgressive bosses is itself a cultural symptom. McKenna and Frankel note people are titillated by Miranda because current workplace culture has clamped down on what you can say. Same dynamic that draws people to Trump or unrestrained billionaires — vicarious fantasy of “crushing everything in your sight.”

  11. Modern leadership style is genuinely different. Frankel: today’s leaders are less demanding, more understanding. Anna Wintour’s successor Chloe Mall talks about paying staff more and how hard they work. Different generation, different expectations.

  12. The cashmere prison. Swisher’s coinage for billionaire isolation: plane → chief → chiefs of staff. Once isolated from normal experience, “the molecules of your brain change so things seem possible that maybe shouldn’t be.” Even the “good ones” can flip. The line in the film — “How long have you owned this house?” “I have no idea.” — captures it.

  13. Costume as character. Costume designer Molly Rogers (inherited Patricia Field’s mantle) used Dior for Emily, vintage layered for Andy (“she speaks French but not perfect French”), and brand-name samurai armor for Miranda. Her rule: “Sometimes the right earrings are from CVS.” Real designers, not invented ones, this time around.

Actionable insights:

  • For young creatives: McKenna’s career advice — “Think about what you love to do, but also think about what do you want your days to be like? How soft do you need your pants to be? Do you need someone to tell you where to go to lunch?” Choose by day-to-day texture, not by glamour. She picked screenwriting over TV writing when her kids were young because screenwriting lets you stay home.
  • Educate yourself on day-to-day reality, not the abstract job. Don’t choose a career on its mythology; choose it on its lived schedule.
  • Develop authentic taste over time. McKenna’s fashion-journey anecdote: she became cool by deliberately experimenting in vintage shops. Taste is a craft.
  • Visionary or vendor. Line in the film: are you a visionary or a vendor? In the agency-shrinking world of media, the writer becomes an entrepreneur with a satchel — know which you are.
  • The system is not your friend. “We don’t have a sister country who cares about you… we’re not going to make an accommodation. If you want balance, you have to do it.” Don’t outsource your work-life choices to your industry.
  • Journalists/ creatives in 2026 must operate with assumption of consolidation and ownership flips. The Paramount/Warner Brothers deal context, Trump pressure on Disney/Kimmel, Ellison family changes at CBS — all signal cycles where employers can change values overnight. Build optionality.

Chapter Summaries

  1. Why a sequel after 18 years of resistance — McKenna and Frankel resisted legacy sequels for 18 years; the spark came from realizing how much CEO/leader reputations had been upended by the internet. “What if Miranda got in trouble and Andy was the one who could help?”

  2. Why the studio said yes — Streep’s interest, then McKenna’s pitch to the new studio president. The audience-of-women market is consistently underrated despite repeated success.

  3. Movies must be events now — The bar for theatrical release has risen sharply. Originals (Sinners, One Battle After Another, Weapons) are breaking through because audiences crave authenticity vs. AI-uncanny content.

  4. Power dynamic flip — Andy now in middle management; sees Miranda’s vulnerability. McKenna parallels growing up and realizing your parents are fallible.

  5. Miranda as hero, not villain — McKenna pitched the studio with this framing. Streep has long argued the gender double standard makes Miranda special.

  6. Generational shift in workplace norms — Today’s workers expect their feelings considered. Frankel and McKenna both started in “who cares about your feelings, get the job done” eras.

  7. Justin Theroux’s Benji as Bezos-Musk composite — Aqua deficit, rocket to the sun, forgetting which houses he owns. Mackenzie Scott reference via Lucy Liu’s ex-wife. Brilliant and odd, Toddler-monster.

  8. The bleak reality of journalism in 2026 — Andy on a “journalist budget” for 20 years. Frankel cites a bank CEO talking about ~100K AI-impacted jobs. LA’s bleakness, hard to point kids in any direction.

  9. Authenticity vs. AI — Pandemonium during shooting. People running into streets. Audiences crave real, in-person things — rise of live events. Costume crew member: “People are craving real stuff.”

  10. Lindsay Peoples question — does the room exist anymore? — Cultural authority has fragmented. No more Walter Cronkite or Diana Vreeland. Set your cap for something that exists.

  11. Amy Larocca question — why does fashion bitchiness still appeal? — The vicarious thrill of unrestrained behavior. Same energy as Trump appeal: “boy, would I love to crush everything in my sight.”

  12. Costume as character — Patricia Field’s mantle to Molly Rogers. Real designers (Dior for Emily). Andy speaks “French but not perfect French” via vintage. “Sometimes the right earrings are from CVS.”

  13. Tech, Trump, Hollywood, media intersection — Paramount/Warner deal anxiety. Trump pressure on Disney over Kimmel. Bezos at WaPo. The McKenna line: “When it’s not their core business, they can delete it like that.”

  14. The cashmere prison — Once you’re flying private, with chiefs of staff in every city, “things seem possible that maybe shouldn’t seem possible.” The “rich don’t get cold anymore” anecdote.

  15. AI predictions — Frankel pessimistic: AI will roll over film “like Pompeii’s lava.” McKenna skeptical based on current chatbot stupidity but acknowledges this view will age poorly. Music is the canary.

  16. Was the sacrifice worth it? — Frankel: yes, Miranda’s regret about missing kids’ lives is real, but the rewards are also real. McKenna’s career-design advice for young people: pick the day-to-day texture you want, not the glamour. Anne Hathaway is in her 40s without kids/marriage as a deliberate counter-narrative to the tradwife era.