The Best Places to Retire, and Play It Safer Before Retirement
Most important take away
If you are within a decade of retirement, research shows that portfolio returns in the years immediately before retirement have the greatest impact on retirement spending outcomes. This means it may be wise to shift a portion of your portfolio toward safer assets like bonds and cash, even if you have been an aggressive investor, to protect against a bear market derailing your retirement plans.
Chapter Summaries
Market Volatility and Diversification
The S&P 500 is only down about 3% for the year, but extreme divergence exists underneath: 57 stocks are up 20%+ and 47 are down 20%+. Tech software (IGV ETF) has dropped 20%, while energy is up 30%. Motley Fool CEO Tom Gardner recommends owning at least 50 stocks (up from 25) to ride out volatility as the market remains richly valued.
The Retirement Risk Zone
A Think Advisor article by leading retirement researchers found that returns in the years immediately before retirement have the greatest impact on retirement outcomes, even more than returns after retirement. Target date funds for those near retirement hold 50-67% stocks, suggesting those in the “retirement risk zone” (roughly 10 years before retirement) should consider dialing back risk.
Bond Yields and Interest Rates
The 10-year Treasury yield rose to 4.32%, driven by inflation fears from the war in Iran and rising oil prices. The Fed held rates steady, and futures now predict only one rate cut (down from three before the war). The 30-year mortgage rate climbed to 6.36%. Higher rates are a global trend.
Best Places to Retire — Methodology and Rankings
A Motley Fool survey of Americans 55+ identified seven key retirement factors: quality of life (31%), healthcare access (15%), housing affordability (13%), climate safety (12%), weather (12%), taxes (11%), and non-housing affordability (6%). The top 10 counties: (1) Broward County, FL (Fort Lauderdale), (2) St. John’s County, FL (St. Augustine), (3) Gadsden County, FL (Quincy), (4) Cuyahoga County, OH (Cleveland), (5) Pulaski County, AR (Little Rock), (6) Philadelphia County, PA, (7) Ramsey County, MN (St. Paul), (8) Milwaukee County, WI, (9) Miami-Dade County, FL, (10) Armstrong County, PA.
Relocating in Retirement — Practical Considerations
About 38% of Americans move after retiring. Key considerations include proximity to family (though research on moving near grandkids is mixed), healthcare access, tax-friendliness relative to your income bracket, whether your home will meet your needs as you age, and the emotional stress of both retiring and moving simultaneously. A test run via Airbnb rental is recommended.
Second Homes and Vacation Rentals
Modern platforms like Airbnb and lower-cost property management (around 15% vs. the old 50%) have made owning a second home more practical. A vacation rental can serve as both a future retirement home and a current income-generating asset, offering flexibility in retirement planning.
Health and Wealth Connection
The U.S. now has more spas and gyms than retail stores. Research shows brisk walking for 30 minutes five days a week decreases risk of cardiovascular disease, diabetes, cognitive impairment, and improves sleep and longevity. Healthier people tend to be wealthier and vice versa.
Summary
Stocks and Investments Mentioned:
- S&P 500 — Down ~3% YTD but with extreme stock-level divergence
- IGV (iShares Expanded Tech-Software Sector ETF) — Down 20% YTD
- Energy sector — Up 30% YTD, the clear winner
- Financials sector — Down 10% YTD, the worst performer, partly on private credit market fears
- 10-year Treasury — Yielding 4.32%, up from 3.97% pre-war
- Target date funds (2030 and 2035 vintages) from American Funds, BlackRock, Fidelity, T. Rowe Price, and Vanguard referenced for asset allocation guidance
Actionable Insights:
-
Diversify broadly — Own at least 50 individual stocks rather than 25 to better weather volatility in a richly valued market expected to deliver below-average returns over the next decade.
-
Reduce risk as retirement approaches — If you are within 10 years of retirement, consider shifting toward a more conservative allocation. Target date funds suggest 50-67% stocks and 33-50% bonds/cash for those 4-9 years from retirement. Returns just before retirement matter most.
-
Do not panic over headline index numbers — The S&P 500 being down only 3% masks massive rotation underneath. Sector and stock selection matter enormously right now.
-
Factor in rising borrowing costs — With mortgage rates at 6.36% and only one Fed rate cut expected, plan accordingly if you intend to buy property in retirement.
-
Consider relocating strategically — Moving from a high-cost to a low-cost area can boost retirement security by freeing up home equity and reducing ongoing expenses (taxes, utilities, upkeep). The full report is available at fool.com/research/best-places-to-retire.
-
Test before you move — Rent in a prospective retirement location for weeks or months, across different seasons, before committing. Research on moving near grandkids shows mixed results for happiness.
-
Explore a second-home strategy — Modern short-term rental platforms have made owning a vacation/future retirement home more financially viable, with management fees around 15% instead of 50%.
-
Invest in your health — A daily 30-minute brisk walk five days a week significantly reduces health risks and improves longevity, directly supporting financial well-being through lower medical costs and greater productivity.